I would argue that overall we are giving up bad to get nothing? We are very tentative when it comes to looking at transfers. The non-grad transfers we've brought in overall seem to be moderate to good (Marshall/Blake?/TJ). The grad-transfers we've brought in overall seem to be poor to moderate (Kwesi/JMA/Noah).
6 transfers in over 14 seasons (less than 1 every 2 years) is probably pretty low-rate compared to D1 averages I assume (EDIT: looks like the current transfer rate is about 14% so 1.82 players per year if I’m reading it correctly). By comparison, we have had 17 (Schneider, Khwan, Buck, Ford, Stansbury, Pistokache, Dominaus, JJones, Smithen, Dominaus, ANO, Singleton, Big Luke, Morris, Crank, Brewster, Sanders) guys transfer or leave the program, not including non-scholarship guys who have come and gone. So we are better than average on guys going out (about 9% on average).
So 17 out, 6 in. It's hard to say if we're giving up good to get bad or bad to get good. I'd say more than anything we're just giving up guys. Some of that is normal and frankly healthy, but it's not healthy that our default reaction most times is to get a high school recruit as it impacts the overall experience and maturity of the team.