Appreciate your perspective, but, I disagree with the "Nelson not a stretch" assertion.it didn't work out perfectly, but tough to argue with the 3 transfers he landed. all fit our needs.
there's no doubt Nelson has talent. we've started freshmen before with success. believing he was next in line wasn't a stretch. and Dji also has talent as a PG, though I think he'll do more as a non-PG with PG skills.
If Mooney read Nelson's resume and press clippings then I 100% agree that Nelson being next in line wasn't a stretch. I thought (and said) the same before I saw him play. However, Mooney saw Nelson in-person, every day for two seasons. We only saw him occasionally (in games). From what I saw of him, It was immediately apparent that he had major deficiencies in his game that made him not ready for the keys to the kingdom.
p.s. I've never said that Nelson has no talent, but it was obvious that he had no business being an A-10 starter and team quarterback in his first year. Much the same as it was with Isiah Wilson.
As the coach, Mooney is expected to be able to properly assess his players. At his rate of compensation, it isn't too much to ask. In my opinion, several missteps could have happened with Nelson. None of them inspire a ton of confidence. 1) Coach's assessment was that Nelson was ready to be next in line, (Mooney hinted at this in pre-season). 2) Coach's assessment was that Nelson wasn't ready to be next in line but he put him in place anyway, 3) Coach felt that he had no choice but Nelson.
If # 1 was the problem, that speaks to a coaching competence issue. If # 2 was the problem, that speaks to a coach decision-making (competence) issue. If # 3 was the problem, that speaks to multiple lines of program failure which fall squarely on the shoulders of the coach. After watching Nelson daily for nearly 2-years, Mooney should have known that handing him the keys to the car wasn't going to promote maximum success.