I believe that Huesman stated during an interview after the PL announcement that we run into PL schools far more often than W & M on the recruiting circuit. I think we've got to give it a chance before we jump off the cliff. Perhaps if we beat the crap out of them for years they'll kick it up a notch or two. I still believe the CAA will implode.
The question might be do Spiders usually get the ones with CAA talent when they bump into PL while recruiting.
The CAA may implode, but the new members might just as well start getting more CAA talent after moving up to the conference and get better.
i would point to Monmouth as an example. They are third year in CAA I believe and have gone from doormat to averaging over 40 points per game in the CAA, but their defense is still weak, so admittedly not there yet. They are good enough right now however they IMO will ruin a team or twos playoff chances in the next five weeks, since they have the top half of the conference standings left excepting the Spiders.
If you get a chance listen to the Bryant coach's press conference from the list of CAA coaches from this week. He talks about having to play many freshmen because they are the only CAA talent they have on the team and the rest of the roster is NEC talent. It will take these new schools a couple of years, but I suspect they will begin to catch up. They probably will not be JMU good, but some of them will contend.
Kind of long winded, so I will stop with my worry about going to PL. Do these new teams begin to get CAA talent in the future and the Spiders become their tune up OOC games with PL talent? That said. do the Spiders dominate in PL and then get beat 40 -14 in the first round every year in the playoffs as usually happens to the PL champion now. I will also admit I was extremely impressed with the committed recruits list coming in next fall, so maybe the coaching staff can pull this off, time will tell.
Not being argumentative, and my opinion does not matter, but I do not believe PL football is at the highest-level Richmond is capable of and it is highly likely the PL would have taken Spiders after the CAA imploded. if it happens.