I did a quick and silly analysis to see which of the top conferences were overrated by the selection committee by seeing which of the top conferences have won the highest percentage of their first round NCAA games.
Underrated
ACC (86%, 7 teams)
Big East (80%, 5 teams)
A10 (66%, 3 teams)
SEC (66%, 3 teams)
B10 (57%, 7 teams)
B12 (43%, 7 teams)
P12 (29%, 7 teams)
AAC (25%, 4 teams)
Overrated
As everyone could tell as soon as the brackets were released the selection committee extremely overrated the AAC and P12. The A10 is holding its own and showing we deserved the bids we got and probably deserved more.
Underrated
ACC (86%, 7 teams)
Big East (80%, 5 teams)
A10 (66%, 3 teams)
SEC (66%, 3 teams)
B10 (57%, 7 teams)
B12 (43%, 7 teams)
P12 (29%, 7 teams)
AAC (25%, 4 teams)
Overrated
As everyone could tell as soon as the brackets were released the selection committee extremely overrated the AAC and P12. The A10 is holding its own and showing we deserved the bids we got and probably deserved more.