Truth# 1: EVERYONE on this site wants to see the Spiders win. Cannibalizing another fan because they have the guts to speak what they see as the truth is nothing more than a veiled attempt at censorship. The goal of that type of comment is to shame, embarrass, and marginalize another fan. It is pathetic really, and shows weakness not strength.
Truth # 2: The Spider basketball program is mediocre AT BEST. Yes, the Spiders win slightly more than 1-2 games. Yes, they finish in the middle of the pack most years. Yes, occasionally they are a little bit better than the norm. Yes, every season has not been as bad as this one. BUT, 2 NCAA's in 13 years is plainly not getting it done. The performance of the basketball program is unacceptable to most sports fans.
Truth # 3: The conditions to WIN and WIN BIG are in place at Richmond. The salary of the coach is enough to attract and keep a much higher performer. The basketball reputation (especially in the past) is such that we should be able to recruit players who can win at a high level. In fact quite a few exceptional players (though not enough) have been here under Mooney. The facilities (arena) are top notch (improved with the practice facility). The A-10 is a league that can attract top players AND provide multiple bids to the tournament. The reputation of the school is well above average. The city is a desirable destination town.
Truth # 4: There have been quite a few teams in the Mooney era who COULD have made the NCAA tournament but did not. This is obviously an opinion, but those who know basketball (here and elsewhere) can confirm the thought. Those who know basketball KNOW that Mooney has quite a few fatal flaws as a coach. These flaws have been addressed on this forum repeatedly so I will not rehash. His flaws are basketball truisms, not just some wild ass opinions of a hand full of big mouths. Because of these flaws, Mooney will NEVER be a coach capable of taking this program where we want it to be. This understanding is proven as a fact over the thirteen year (14 if you include his mediocre season at Air Force) sample size.
Truth # 5: Those on this forum who are adamant about Mooney being released DO NOT hate Mooney as a person (at least so far as I know). The comments on this forum are directed at his inability to achieve at the desired level. Nothing more, nothing less.
In summary, Truths 1-5 are the reasons that so many are demanding change. We will be better off if a large sample size on this board demonstrates a thicker skin when someone says something with which they disagree. It is too often arrogant and thin skinned ridiculousness. We have different experiences and perspectives, thus we have different opinions. If we listen respectfully, we might learn something. VT and fatherspider are perfect examples of this point. Many here don't like the way in which they express their views (which is your right), but like the rest of us, they are correct at least as much as they are wrong.
The calls for Mooney's scalp are not personal. The snide name calling, questioning of fan credentials, and arrogant responses to those who issue the calls shouldn't be personal either.